Who do we call when waste collection system fails?

An exclusive control room meant for garbage complaints will help in handling the situation better in Bengaluru.

I have been working closely with the door-to-door collection in our ward, with the residents on the one hand, the garbage collectors and the BBMP officials on the other hand. There is one question that always comes up within a few minutes of interaction. Who do we call, if the auto guy does not turn up for collection? If a house in our street is not segregating? if somebody is found dumping? If the sweeper is burning leaves? If the black spot near my house is not cleared?

A dump in Malleshwaram Pic: Ramesh Sreekantan

A simple enough question — with no simple answers, it seems. Everyone has a past experience of no response, unresolved complaints and too much follow up.

So much of what the BBMP door-to-door collection does is in the nature of a service. So a closed loop system to take care of grievance redressal, feedback through appropriate response and action taken is key to managing the humongous task of ensuring efficient door-to-door collection system.

It starts with finding the right answer to the question — ‘Who do we call…?’

Complaint lodging mechanism with the BBMP

The  complaint lodging mechanism that exists needs to be addressed and strengthened.

Current system: Complaints are today made directly to the BBMP officials.

Problems with this are:

  1. This is essentially one-to-one communication. Only the person making the complaint and the BBMP officials know of the complaint, so we are dependent on the strength of the individual personalities (influential person etc) to get the complaint resolved.

  2. The BBMP officials are very often overwhelmed with the number and nature of  complaints. Receiving complaints directly can be unpleasant and puts officials on the defensive. It is possible that the officials receive too many complaints and cannot address it singly.

  3. It is also time-consuming to receive and answer many complaint calls. Officials’ time should be used for operations, not receiving complaints directly.

  4. There is no record / history of the complaint, therefore no data available on recurrent / chronic complaints, serious complaints, how many problems resolved/ unresolved etc. There is therefore no data available for taking action on the people responsible for the lapse.

  5. Escalation of the problem does not take place. Senior officers are kept unaware of the problems at the level of Assistant Executive Engineer, Assistant Engineer, Junior Health Inspector level, when it is not reported.

Role of the Control Room – BBMP for complaint redressal from citizens

Even though a Control Room exists, this is not addressing the problems effectively.

Current system:

  1. Every Zone has a Control Room. It is manned by an operator in two shifts. One telephone line and one wireless system.

  2. The operator registers the complaint manually in the register and passes it on through wireless / telephone to the concerned official.

  3. At present the Control Room West Zone has no wireless communication system.  The transmission tower is down. Officers are also not using their wireless systems and communicate on their phones.

  4. The Control Room, West receives only 25 complaints for the Zone in a week. The Control Room is presently used for paging officers, internal  communication/ information dissemination on meetings etc.

Problems with this are:

BBMP Control Rooms are weak and ineffective. They do not instill confidence in the public.  Information flow is non-existent. There is no closing of loop system on the complaint.

Suggested mechanisms to improve the functioning of the Control Room

How:

  1. Complaints, grievances from the General Public should be registered with the Control Room.

  2. Complaints must have a computerised recording system, with a number generated for tracking each complaint

  3. Response time must be fixed for every category of complaint

  4. Trained operators should handle the call centres

  5. Review of pending complaints must be taken up by the Zonal level Officers on a daily basis

  6. Reports on complaints, which ward, nature, periodicity of complaints must be generated.

  7. Accountability and escalation protocols must be set up

 

Who:

  1. BBMP should set it up

  2. Independent complaint/ grievance platforms either through NGOs or citizen-operated

 

 

Related Articles

To take waste management to the next level
A large scale composting model Bangalore’s apartments can emulate

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Story

Marooned and abandoned: Study reveals displaced families were put in the path of floods

Perumbakkam in Chennai has faced floods in 2015, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2023. Despite that, 12,045 families were resettled there since 2015.

When Cyclone Michaung-induced floods hit the resettlement colonies of Perumbakkam, the houses on the ground floor were quickly inundated. On a priority basis, persons with disabilities were allocated houses on the ground floor. However, with the floods, their vulnerability pushed them further to the fringes. They were forced to climb stairs seeking refuge in other people's homes that already had leaky roofs and damp walls. This was not the first time people in resettlement colonies in Perumbakkam or Semmencherry were facing floods. Almost every year, November and December are months of struggle for the families, who are evicted and resettled…

Similar Story

Matharpacady: Resisting hot real estate deals to conserve century-old heritage

Despite the challenges of maintaining heritage houses, the residents of Matharpacady want to save the precinct for culture and community.

Renie Baptista, lives in a 100-old-legacy house in Matharpacady. The house, inherited by her father-in-law from his mother, invokes a mixture of legacy, emotional attachment to the neighbourhood, where people share similar cultural and social ethos. She also enjoys a sense of space in her 2000 sq ft bungalow, which, even now, is a sturdy house.  Shifting into a flat that could come with water and other infrastructural issues bothers her along with the worry of losing her link with her community spaces forever. Many others in Matharpacady share her anxiety. The quaint old charming bungalows and bylanes of Mazgaon village…