Metro Reach 3B to be a reality soon: Why commuters may yet not use it

Pic courtesy: BMRCL facebook page

After repeated delays in meeting the original schedule, Bangalore Metro is set to extend its footprint in North Bengauru. However, the extension is a mere 2.5 kilometres on Reach 3 (B) – the Peenya Industry – Nagasandra stretch. The trial runs began on September 30, 2014, and the service is likely to be inaugurated in December 2014 or January 2015. The three new stations on this stretch are T Dasarahalli, Jalahalli and Nagasandra. The Nagasandra station is located at a distance of around 12.8 km from Mantri Square station.

Will Reach 3B of Metro make an impact?

This however, is unlikely to make any sort of impact on the existing mess, which exists on NH4 that goes towards Tumkur. The Metro Reach 3 and Reach 3A inaugurated on March 1, 2014 along with the elevated highway has not made any difference to the existing mess on this road. The traffic at various junctions such as Jalahalli, Goraguntepalya remain as chaotic as before and there is no reduction in traffic volumes so to speak of.

As per a report from Deccan Herald, the ridership on weekdays on this stretch is 15,000. This goes up to 20,000 on weekends. Bangalore Metro had estimated a ridership of 50,000 on this stretch. BMRCL opines that the ridership may go up by 5,000 after the extension. Last mile connectivity, lack of coordination between Metro and other transport agencies such as SWR (South Western Railways) and BMTC, Metro services for latenighters, bad design of stations (Peenya and Peenya Industrial Estate stations), incomplete civil works and disruptions are cited as some of the reasons for poor patronage.

Parking lots at stations

Metro’s ridership has not reached the mark as a lot of issues have not been addressed. A major issue, which remains unaddressed even today in so far as Bangalore Metro is concerned, is last mile connectivity.

People who have travelled on the Delhi metro would acquiesce that the stations at DMRC are much better-equipped and designed. For starters, most metro stations in New Delhi have parking lots, which means the issue of connectivity till doorstep is assured.

BMRCL has parking lots only at Swamy Vivekananda and Byappanhalli stations currently, but nowhere on Reach 3A-B. The other way by which, this issue could have been addressed is through better co-ordination with BMTC.

Route map of 3B. The red circle marks the KSRTC bus stand in Peenya, which is one km away from Metro station.

Need for feeder services

BMTC has withdrawn its feeder service from Mantri Mall to Majestic, which means many long distance commuters are inconvenienced. Passengers are left in the middle of nowhere as they alight at the Mantri Square station.

The situation is  similar at Peenya Industry Metro Station, as commuters get off  and try to reach their homes or workplaces off Tumkur road. There are no separate feeder services available here as well. The auto drivers of Bangalore are the biggest beneficiaries in a scenario like this.   

Bhavin Gandhi, a resident of Rajajinagar and a frequent user of this service opines that withdrawal of feeder services to Majestic from Mantri has led to a fall in ridership. He says, “Commuters are forced to use regular services to Majestic instead of the metro feeder buses, which were available earlier. This is not only an expensive proposition but we are also forced to jostle with regular commuters on this crowded route.”

There seems to be an issue in connecting Peenya Metro station with the new Satellite Bus stand as well. BMTC, BMRCL and KSRTC need to come together and market their services so that people use KSRTC’s services to get to other towns in Karnataka. KSRTC’s idea of decongesting Majestic albeit a noble one has not succeeded as they did not coordinate with Metro and BMTC well enough. The result: private bus operators are making a killing.

Sanjeev Dyamannavar of Praja RAAG (A citizen’s Initiative for civic needs) has often stressed on the need on integrating Metro with Railways and BMTC. He says, “The new satellite bus stand is just a kilometre away from Peenya Metro station but BMRCL and BMTC have shown no desire to integrate bus and metro services.”

On the other hand,  Veeregowda G N, General Manager – traffic for BMTC, said that the feeder services were withdrawn after BMTC found that people were not using them. It is not clear whether they did it on the basis of any survey, was there enough publicity given to these buses, were public aware of it etc.

BMRCL may have accomplished a lot of firsts in Bangalore, however they need to get their act together as far as their co-ordination with civic agencies and other transport corporations are concerned.

Peenya and Peenya Industry’s Metro station needs

As a recent press report in Udayavani pointed out, it is extremely difficult to cross the road as one gets off the train at Peenya and Peenya Industrial estate metro stations. The stations are located on one side of the road and there is no access to it from the other side. Given the huge volume of traffic that this road sees, crossing the road is a risky affair. The iron railings on the pavements and the huge dividers also make crossing the road a difficult task. People, therefore find it easier to use the bus than risk their lives trying to cross the road, if bus services are provided. Basics like exits and entrances to the Metro station on both sides of the roads should have been taken care of.

What needs to be done by Namma Metro

There needs to be separate Metro feeder service from all the Metro stations to all the residential and commercial neighbourhoods, which form the catchment areas for all these stations.

Right now, the situation is such that Metro commuters are forced to depend upon regular BMTC services or autos to reach their destination. Residents of localities such as Basaveshwarnagar, Gayatri Nagar, Nandini Layout, Gelayarabalaga, Kurubarahalli, Malleswaram, Rajajinagar (III, IV, V, and VI Blocks), Seshadripuram, interior parts of Mahalakshmi Layout etc. could benefit immensely if Metro feeder services are provided.  

The much neglected industrial estate of Peenya will also benefit immensely if Metro feeder buses are provided. This needs to be taken into consideration and implemented at least once the North-South corridor is complete.

Related Articles

Metro to reach Sarjapur Road!
BBMP plans to merge Silk Board elevated road with Metro line
Can we have Metro to Whitefield upon the existing railway track?

About Amith Subramanian Pallavoor 0 Articles
Amith Subramanian Pallavoor is a Freelance Management Consultant and writer, based in Bengaluru.

5 Comments

  1. We are yet to hear on the inauguration of this stretch. Does it take more than a year just to complete 2.5 kms?

  2. a tiny miniscule fraction of the city is covered by metro..until the metro grows to 200-250 km long and spreads across a larger geographic region that needs it (jayanagar koramangala to CBD/indiranagar for example) – there wont be much traffic reducaion…

  3. I commute the same route every day. To state the facts there is rarely anyone getting in after jalahalli cross till the bus reaches goruguntepalya. With the same facts in consideration it does not make any sense for the two stations i.e. peenya and peenya industry to contribute in making any money for the metro. more over it will only make losses. Add to that the accessibility problem of these two stations. for the second part if a bus goes via rajajinagar you wont find anyone even on a bus to travel to majestic even when the number of buses are very less. but with a huge number of buses going through malleshwaram the buses are always jam packed and most of the buses are empty by the time it reaches link road which is the one just before matri square. The idea of having the metro line through rajaji nagar thus seems to be ridiculous. So to sum up it will not much difference to the number of commuters in the metro unless and until the link is complete between north and K R Market for which insidentaly BMTC does not have much service in that direction. So dont expect any big changes in profitability.

  4. I wonder….

    A. Are the designers & decision makers in BMRCL unable to understand the need for pedestrian over bridges across a busy highway?; and those in BMTC were acutely conscious of commercial losses ONLY on the feeder services?

    OR

    B. Vested interests have made sure the citizen “does NOT” matter!

    One potential solution that will make the wonderful staff jump to action:

    Get both BMRCL & BMTC senior staff to cross the highway in peak hour traffic twice daily for a week.

    We all we be pleasantly surprised to see useful, concrete proposals on the need for pedestrian safety & last mile connectivity being sanctioned & implementation started, before the week is out!

  5. As pointed out, i’ve always given feedback about Peenya Metro stn which has accessibility issues, to cross over railings but nothing has changed yet.

    Also, the repetition of stn names with different suffix are quite confusing, Peenya, Peenya industry so on.. They should have used old names like Gorguntepalya instead YPR Industry (nobody can remember the exact location. The present Peenya metro stn is called CMTI Bus stop and Peenya Bus stop is further 1 km from CMTI. There is no coordination of bus stop and metro stn name)

    Many commuters are hesitant to use metro service now as it hardly saves any time. It takes 10 mins to get in and get out of station and 20 mins to travel to Mantri.. but it takes 40 mins to reach same point in bus which will continue to KBS..

    Adding Reach 3B will have a good turn out, as it crosses the main junctions like 8th mile, J cross, G palya and YPR all at once.. hence the office working community will be more than happy to use it, provided proper installation of pedestrian under or over pass in Peenya, J cross, Dasarahalli and Widia(Deepak), nowhere after G palya towards Tumkur road we have this facility so commuters wouldn’t try risk themselves to cross highway roads.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


Please solve this *